PawSums

Are Poinsettias Poisonous to Cats and Dogs? And the Christmas Plants That Are Worse

On this page
  1. What happens if a cat or dog eats a poinsettia
  2. When to call your vet or a poison line
  3. Christmas plants compared
  4. Lilies: the real danger for cats
  5. The Christmas tree
  6. Safer ways to decorate
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Sources

Yes, but only mildly. The ASPCA lists the poinsettia as toxic to dogs and cats, and in the same entry calls it "generally over-rated in toxicity." Pet Poison Helpline says the plants "are only mildly toxic to cats and dogs" and that the poisoning "is greatly exaggerated." The ASPCA's holiday safety tips put it a little more strongly: poinsettias "can also make pets sick with mild to moderate gastrointestinal irritation." So a pet that chews a leaf usually gets an upset mouth and stomach. The Christmas plant to worry about is a different one: lilies in holiday bouquets can cause kidney failure in cats.

Below: what a poinsettia does to a cat or dog, when to call for help, and how the other plants of the season compare.

What happens if a cat or dog eats a poinsettia

The irritant is in the milky sap. Pet Poison Helpline lists these signs to watch for:

  • Drooling
  • Licking lips
  • Vomiting
  • Diarrhea
  • Skin irritation (including redness, swelling, and itchiness)
  • Eye irritation

Skin signs come from contact with the milky sap, and eye exposure can rarely cause mild irritation. Diarrhea is less common: when a pet eats the plant, the helpline expects "mild signs of vomiting, drooling, or rarely, diarrhea." It also says the signs "are generally self-limiting and typically don't require medical treatment unless severe and persistent," and that there is no antidote.

Pet Poison Helpline rates the toxicity level as mild for both dogs and cats.

When to call your vet or a poison line

Our suggestion: call if the signs are severe or keep going, if you are not sure which plant your pet ate, or if your pet also got into something else, such as a bouquet with lilies or a box of chocolates. In the US:

  • ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center: (888) 426-4435, open 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. A consultation fee may apply.
  • Pet Poison Helpline: (855) 764-7661, open 24/7. A $99 per incident fee applies, and follow-up consultations are included.

Pet Poison Helpline's advice is not to make your pet vomit on your own: "Do NOT induce vomiting without consulting a vet or Pet Poison Helpline."

Christmas plants compared

The ASPCA's plant database covers the common holiday plants. Here is how they compare:

PlantDogsCatsWhat the ASPCA lists
PoinsettiaToxic (ASPCA); mild (Pet Poison Helpline)Toxic (ASPCA); mild (Pet Poison Helpline)Irritating to the mouth and stomach, sometimes vomiting
Lilies (Easter lily and other true lilies)Non-toxic (ASPCA, Easter lily); FDA: minor stomach upset possibleToxicVomiting, inappetence, lethargy, kidney failure; death is possible
American mistletoeToxicToxicVomiting, diarrhea, low blood pressure (rare), difficulty breathing, low heart rate
HollyToxicToxicVomiting, diarrhea and depression; leaves and berries are low toxicity
AmaryllisToxicToxicVomiting, depression, diarrhea, abdominal pain, hypersalivation, anorexia, tremors
Christmas cactusNon-toxicNon-toxicNon-toxic to dogs and cats

The "mild" rating for the poinsettia comes from Pet Poison Helpline; the ASPCA lists it as toxic. The holly entry is for American holly (Ilex opaca). The ASPCA's holiday advice groups mistletoe and holly together: both "can cause gastrointestinal upset and cardiovascular problems if ingested by pets."

Lilies: the real danger for cats

Lilies turn up in Christmas and winter bouquets, and for a cat they can be a medical emergency. The FDA explains that lilies in the "true lily" and "daylily" families are very dangerous for cats and that the entire plant is toxic: "the stem, leaves, flowers, pollen, and even the water in a vase."

A small exposure is enough. In the FDA's words, eating "just a small amount of a leaf or flower petal, licking a few pollen grains off its fur while grooming, or drinking the water from the vase can cause your cat to develop fatal kidney failure in less than 3 days."

Time matters. According to the FDA, early signs (less activity, drooling, vomiting, loss of appetite) start 0 to 12 hours after the cat eats part of a lily, and kidney failure follows within 24 to 72 hours if the cat is not treated. "Early veterinary treatment greatly improves the cat's prognosis," but if treatment is delayed by 18 hours or more, the cat will generally have irreversible kidney failure. The FDA's advice: if you suspect that your cat has eaten any part of a lily or its pollen, or has drunk water from a vase with lilies, "immediately call your veterinarian or a pet poison control center." Our suggestion is to call even if your cat seems fine, because the early signs can take hours to show and the window for effective treatment is short.

The FDA's list of the most dangerous lilies for cats includes the Asiatic, Easter, Japanese show, Oriental, rubrum, stargazer, tiger and wood lily, and the daylily. Its advice is simple: if you have a cat, it's best not to bring these plants into your home.

Not every plant called a lily is a true lily. The FDA explains that calla lilies and peace lilies don't cause kidney failure in cats, but can irritate the mouth and throat. Lily-of-the-valley is a different danger: it is "very dangerous to cats and dogs" because its toxins can make the heart beat abnormally.

Dogs are different. The FDA notes that dogs that eat lilies "may have minor stomach upset but they don't develop kidney failure."

The Christmas tree

The tree is not on the plant lists above, but the ASPCA's holiday safety tips mention three things:

  • Secure the tree. Make sure it "is tightly secured so there is no chance it can tip over and hurt any pets nearby."
  • Cover the tree water. "Tree water is a breeding ground for bacteria that could cause nausea, diarrhea or stomach upset."
  • Skip the tinsel, especially with cats. "Ingested tinsel can cause severe vomiting, obstructed digestive tract, dehydration and could even require surgery."

Safer ways to decorate

  • Keep real poinsettias, mistletoe, holly and amaryllis where your pets can't reach them, or follow the ASPCA's suggestion and use a faux version of the holiday plant instead.
  • Leave lilies out of the house if you have a cat, as the FDA advises. We also suggest asking friends to leave them out of the flowers they bring.
  • A Christmas cactus is listed by the ASPCA as non-toxic to dogs and cats.
  • Food is a Christmas risk too: the ASPCA warns that fatty, sweet and spicy foods and turkey or chicken bones "can all be dangerous to our pets." See our guide to holiday foods that are toxic to dogs, and if chocolate goes missing, run the numbers in the chocolate toxicity calculator.

Frequently asked questions

My cat chewed a poinsettia leaf. Is it an emergency?

Usually not. Pet Poison Helpline expects mild signs such as drooling or vomiting that typically settle without treatment. Call your vet or a poison line if the signs are severe or don't stop, or if you are not sure it was a poinsettia and not a lily.

Are poinsettias more dangerous to cats than to dogs?

Pet Poison Helpline rates the poinsettia as mildly toxic to both dogs and cats. For cats, the plant that makes the real difference is the lily.

Is the sap a problem on skin?

It can be. Pet Poison Helpline says sap on the skin can cause redness, swelling and itchiness, and that eye exposure can rarely cause mild irritation.

Is mistletoe worse than poinsettia?

The ASPCA's list of signs for American mistletoe is longer and includes low blood pressure (rare), difficulty breathing and a low heart rate, so we suggest keeping it well out of reach and calling your vet or a poison line if your pet eats some.

Sources